Single-dose capsules or jerrican: which cleaning product format makes sense
Dosing, plastic, transport, storage and safety: where the water-soluble capsule wins, where the jerrican still wins and how to decide site by site.
By Jorge Sánchez · Marketing and IT director
Short answer: water-soluble single-dose capsules make sense when there are many cleaning points, several people preparing product and little storage space; the 5-litre jerrican is still the logical choice where automatic dispensers are installed or scrubber dryers are filled in large volumes. In all other cases the capsule wins on exact dosing, on plastic and on transport.
What exactly is being compared
A jerrican holds concentrated product that someone has to measure: with the cap, with a dispenser or by eye. A single-dose capsule holds a pre-measured dose inside a polyvinyl alcohol (PVOH) film that dissolves in the water of the bucket or bottle. The product can be the same; what changes is who decides the dose.
The comparison, point by point
| Criterion | Water-soluble single-dose capsule | 5 L jerrican |
|---|---|---|
| Dose | Fixed: 5 ml per 5–8 L bucket for floor cleaners; 9 ml per 750 ml bottle for trigger-spray cleaners | Variable: depends on the cap, the dispenser and the person; for a standard concentrate, 20–25 ml per 5 L bucket |
| Yield per pack | Floor cleaner box: 200 capsules = 200 buckets. Trigger-spray cleaner box: 100 capsules = 75 L ready to use | 200 to 250 buckets per jerrican if the dose is respected |
| Plastic | The film dissolves; the trigger bottle is reused and only the capsule is replaced | One jerrican per pack and, if product is decanted, bottles that are refilled or thrown away |
| Transport and storage | You transport the active product, not the water: small, light boxes | Each 5 L jerrican weighs around 5 kg and takes up space in the storeroom and on the trolley |
| Operator safety | No handling of concentrate and no decanting | Contact with concentrate when measuring and decanting, and a risk of unlabelled bottles |
| Ecolabel | ECO+ line with EU Ecolabel in floor cleaner, multi-surface and glass cleaner, anti-limescale bathroom cleaner and laundry detergent | Depends on the product reference |
| Dosing flexibility | One capsule per bucket; for heavy soiling, a second capsule | Can be adjusted to each surface and level of soiling |
Where single-dose capsules win
- Teams spread across several sites or shifts: the dose is the same whoever prepares it, and consumption is as planned.
- Sites with little storage: hotels, offices, schools, care homes or holiday apartments, where there is no room for jerricans.
- Contracts that call for less plastic or proof of environmental criteria: the bottle is reused and the ECO+ line carries EU Ecolabel for public tenders.
- Rotating staff: nothing to explain about dilutions; one capsule, one bucket.
Where the jerrican still wins
- Automatic dispensers already installed in cleaning rooms or laundries, fed from jerricans.
- Scrubber dryers for large areas, which take dozens of litres at a time.
- Products that do not exist in capsule form or that need very different dilutions depending on the surface.
In practice many customers combine both: the 5 L jerrican where there is machinery, and single-dose capsules on the trolleys and at small sites.
How a single-dose capsule cuts plastic
A ready-to-use cleaner is almost all water. With single-dose capsules you buy the active product and prepare it in the same trigger bottle again and again: a box of 100 capsules of 9 ml makes 75 litres of cleaner and means 100 spray bottles you do not buy. The PVOH film dissolves completely; the outer box is recyclable cardboard (paper/cardboard recycling) and the doypacks holding the capsules go in plastic packaging recycling.
How to decide for each site
- Count the cleaning points and the people who prepare product: the more points and people, the more a fixed dose matters.
- Check whether there are dispensers or scrubber dryers: if there are, keep the jerrican for them.
- Check the storage space and how product reaches each site.
- See whether the contract or tender specification requires EU Ecolabel or a reduction in plastic.
- Always compare the cost per bucket, not the price of the pack: we explain it in floor cleaner concentrate: dilution and cost per bucket.
You can see all 23 references, with their dose and technical data sheet, in the catalogue of single-dose capsules for professional cleaning, or ask us for a sample box to try them at one site before switching.